c'mon, man. There's no magic formula that tells you whether you should get one or the other (especially not one that factors in only your year and transmission type). Search and read what has been hashed out many many times before. Then, decide which one is going to suit your needs, based on what you learn.
Plus, it's not like this thread is going to turn up any information that hasn't already been beaten to death in other threads.
A forum community dedicated to Mazda 3 and all Mazda vehicle owners and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about MazdaSpeed performance, modifications, classifieds, troubleshooting, maintenance, and more!